Updated DebitCue Editorial Team

Credit card rewards and perks: what to compare and why

Cash back, points, miles and travel benefits sit on the same cards, so comparing them means checking the earning rate, what it is limited to, and the perks that come with the account.

Four shapes of reward, and only some suit you

Every card in this group pays back in a small number of ways, and the first job is to match that shape to how you actually spend. Cash back needs no conversion step. Absa is a cashback card paying up to 2% cash back, while Advanzia Bank runs the same cashback structure but steers the reward towards travel with 5% back on rental car bookings, 5% travel credit on bookings and asks for no minimum spend.

Points and miles behave differently. A points balance is only worth what you can redeem it for, so read the earn rate and the redemption catalogue together. points sit on AffinityPlus Credit Union, and miles cards collect airline miles you spend on flights. If flying is the plan, our Airline and miles cards round-up is the shortlist to read next.

A fourth group earns nothing back, which is not the same as being a bad card. Those accounts shift the whole case onto perks and running costs, and they suit people who pay their balance in full each month and do not want to chase rewards.

Cash back: the rate, the cap and the period

Cash back looks simple until you read the conditions attached to it. up to 2% cash back is a headline figure, and the question is whether it applies to everything you spend or to selected categories only. Advanzia Bank shows the category version clearly: 5% back on rental car bookings, 5% travel credit on bookings, so the reward follows bookings rather than everyday spending.

Some rates only last. 5% groceries and fuel first 12 months is the plainest example here, because the rate is tied to an opening period rather than to the life of the account. Set that beside 1% cashback on the Avant card, which is a flat rate with no window attached, and the difference over a full year of ordinary spending is easy to see.

Three questions settle most of it: which categories earn the headline rate, is there a ceiling on what you can collect, and what the rate becomes once an introductory period ends. If a card does not answer those plainly, treat the headline as promotional.

Points and miles: what the balance is actually worth

With points and miles, the earn rate is only part of the calculation. The other part is redemption, so compare what a point buys and how many points the card asks for it. A generous earn rate on a thin redemption catalogue is a poor trade.

Different cards weight the same basket very differently. American Airlines pays a base rate of AAdvantage miles on all purchases and a higher rate at grocery stores and on eligible American Airlines purchases, with no cap on the miles earned, so an ordinary household basket can out-earn a travel-heavy one. Al Rajhi Bank does the reverse: a lower rate on domestic spend and a higher rate on international spend, which suits a cardholder paying for things abroad. Its points scheme pairs with lounge access worth more if you fly.

Ties to one scheme narrow your options, so keep that in view. points on AffinityPlus Credit Union come with Visa Signature benefits on top, American Express CH runs points alongside lounge access and Priority Pass, and Amwal keeps credit card points, rewards and miles even on its installment structure, which matters if you already hold balances elsewhere.

Perks that pay for themselves without effort

Insurance and lounge access are the perks that quietly add up, and they are the reason a card with no reward scheme can still make sense. The fullest package here sits on a business card: ABN AMRO Zakelijk adds purchase protection across almost all purchases, SafeGuard Support, travel accident cover, baggage delay and flight delay insurance, a delivery and internet guarantee, round-the-clock fraud prevention, a deposit guarantee on credit card balances and Priority Pass Standard membership with lounge access. The full list sits on the ABN AMRO Zakelijk review.

Travel is where the rest compete. Absa Bank Mauritius pairs airport lounge access with travel insurance. American Express CH bundles lounge access, Priority Pass, an International Airline Program, rental car programs, insurance and a travel and lifestyle service. American Express Oman lists global lounge access, an annual travel credit on the Platinum Card, worldwide travel and retail insurance, purchase and fraud protection, SafeKey, merchant offers and contactless payments. Al Rajhi Bank opens a set of global airport lounges on its platinum card.

Count how many you would use. A lounge pass you never visit is not a saving, while travel cover that protects a real trip is worth more than a slightly better earn rate.

Perks that change what holding the card costs

Not every benefit is travel. Several cards cut the everyday cost of the card instead, and those are easier to value because they touch normal spending rather than holidays.

Amwal charges no Amwal fees or interest on credit card installments, keeps credit card points, rewards and miles, and needs no registration or document uploads. ANZ Credit Cards charge no cost for additional cardholders and work with digital wallets. Avant offers proactive credit line increases, account management in a mobile app, Mastercard zero liability protection and a qualification check that will not affect your credit score. Aqua Card adds instalment plans, offers and discounts in its app, free credit score checks, a credit building tool and credit limit increases for well managed accounts. AVO Bank pairs an interest-free purchase period with extra time to repay, free early repayment, free virtual card issuance and card blocking in the app.

These perks are the reason to accept a card that pays nothing back, and they are worth listing beside the earn rate before you choose.

Cards that earn nothing back

A fair number of the brands here carry no rewards scheme: 1822direkt is marked none for rewards, and the same holds for ABN AMRO Zakelijk, Alif, ANNA Money, ANZ Credit Cards, ANZ Fiji and Arab Bank. 1822direkt is worth reading before you accept the idea that a card with no reward is a wasted card.

Read those accounts as cost and convenience plays. ABN AMRO Zakelijk earns nothing back and compensates with a long perk list, while ANZ Credit Cards and ANZ Fiji concentrate on interest-free days, and Aqua Card and AVO Bank pair low-cost instalments with credit building tools. If you would rather not chase rewards, these are the accounts to weigh, and if your credit history is thin, our bad credit and credit builder cards round-up covers accounts built around that starting point.

Check where the money sits, not just the reward

Perks decide whether a card feels generous. Protection decides whether it is worth keeping, so look at how each brand guards the balance online and at the terminal.

Avant includes Mastercard zero liability protection. Aqua Card offers round-the-clock fraud protection and a contactless Mastercard. AVO Bank adds online purchase security, free virtual card issuance, free balance enquiries in its app and at its own ATMs, and free early repayment. Access Bank Cards includes Verified By Visa for online transactions, accepts cards across a wide network of ATMs and merchant locations worldwide, sets a minimum monthly repayment at a share of the outstanding balance, and allows a credit limit drawn from net monthly salary. The details are in the Access Bank Cards review.

A card that pays you back is worth holding only if you are comfortable with how the money behaves the rest of the time, so put the protection terms next to the earn rate before you apply.

Sources